On September 30, 2026, two Mattapoisett deeds were recorded within a few lines of each other in The Wanderer's real estate transactions table. One was on Pearl Street at about $1.48 million, and the other was on Harbor Road on the Neck at about $1.4 million. Nine days later, a transfer on Channel Street was recorded at $350,000. All three are in the same town and were recorded within about ten days. Nobody would call them the same kind of purchase.
That spread explains the most misleading number on any Mattapoisett search page. The town's single-family median sale price for January through October 2026 was $885,200, up 10.0% from $805,000 over the same months of 2025. At first glance that looks like a town where demand is driving prices up. The rest of the same report points the other way. Fewer homes are selling, more are waiting for buyers, and the median is moving mostly because of which houses happened to close.
Fewer buyers closing, sellers listing at the same pace
Start with the count. Mattapoisett had 65 single-family closings from January through October 2026, against 84 in the same period of 2025, a drop of 22.6%. Pending sales over those months fell from 89 to 70.
New listings held almost perfectly steady. Sellers brought 112 single-family homes to market from January through October 2026, compared with 114 a year earlier. So the supply of sellers did not shrink. The number of deals that reached the closing table did.
When listings keep arriving at the old pace and closings slow, homes pile up. At the end of October 2026, Mattapoisett had 38 single-family homes for sale, up from 30 in October 2025. That works out to 5.9 months of supply, up from 3.6. Months of supply estimates how long the current inventory would last at the recent sales pace. At 5.9, Mattapoisett heads into winter with noticeably more choice on the market than a year ago.
The homes that did sell went fairly smoothly. From January through October 2026, sellers received 95.3% of their original list price on average, about the same as the 94.9% for that period in 2025. Cumulative days on market rose modestly over the same span, from 63 to 68. Put together, priced-right homes still sell within a few points of their asking price in a little over two months. The growing inventory is the houses that have not found a buyer yet.
A median built from a few dozen very different houses
A median is the middle price among whatever closed in a given period. With 65 closings in ten months, a few sales at the top or bottom can move it a long way. The Massachusetts Association of Realtors notes on its Mattapoisett October 2026 report that one month of activity "can sometimes look extreme due to small sample size."
Mattapoisett's last two months show how far it can swing. In September 2026, the town's single-family median was $1,285,000 on 7 closings. In October 2026, it was $690,000 on 8 closings, down 23.7% from October 2025's $904,000. The monthly median follows the mix of what closed. September's few closings leaned toward the top of the town's range, and October's leaned lower.
The deed transfers show what that mix looked like. In mid-September, two transfers recorded on the same day, one on Union Avenue and one on Daisey Way, were each above $1.2 million. The October recordings filled in the middle and lower parts of the range:
| Street | Recorded | Price, rounded |
|---|---|---|
| Channel Street | early October | about $350,000 |
| Brandt Beach Avenue | early October | about $470,000 |
| Michelle Lane | early October | about $575,000 |
| Riverside Lane | mid-October | about $695,000 |
| Winnatuxett Road | late October | about $750,000 |
| Barrett Drive | mid-October | about $840,000 |
| Acushnet Road | early October | about $860,000 |
| Pine Island Road | early October | about $1.2 million |
These are recorded deeds. They do not say what kind of property changed hands, and deed timing differs from the MLS figures behind the monthly report. Still, they show the point: in a single month, Mattapoisett's sales ran from the mid-$300,000s to more than $1 million. The town's median is the middle point of very different purchases, and a buyer's price depends on which kind of house they are after.
How Mattapoisett compares with its neighbors
A buyer comparing towns along the South Coast will usually also be looking at Marion, Fairhaven and Rochester. The same October 2026 reports put the four side by side. Sales, median, days on market and list-price figures cover January through October 2026. Months of supply is an end-of-October snapshot.
| Town | Closed sales | Change | Median price | Change | Months of supply | Days on market | Share of original list price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mattapoisett | 65 | −22.6% | $885,200 | +10.0% | 5.9 | 68 | 95.3% |
| Marion | 47 | −7.8% | $1,000,000 | +42.9% | 7.1 | 74 | 94.3% |
| Fairhaven | 107 | +0.9% | $525,000 | +5.1% | 3.3 | 48 | 97.8% |
| Rochester | 45 | +32.4% | $720,000 | +4.0% | 3.2 | 75 | 97.5% |
Two pairs show up. Mattapoisett and Marion have the highest medians, the most months of supply, and sellers getting about 94% to 95% of their original asking price. Marion's 42.9% median jump came on just 47 sales, so the small-sample caution applies even more there. Fairhaven and Rochester have medians several hundred thousand dollars lower, about three months of supply, and sellers getting closer to 98% of their original price. Rochester is the only one of the four where closings rose, up by about a third.
For a buyer, that splits the region in two. In Fairhaven or Rochester, inventory is tighter and homes sell closer to their original price, so it pays to be ready to act quickly. In Mattapoisett or Marion this winter, a buyer is choosing from a larger pool of higher-priced homes, with sellers there accepting a few more points off their original asking price.
What the 2026 town votes added to supply
A larger pool of listings eventually draws new construction in some markets. In Mattapoisett, this year's town votes kept new housing small in scale.
At the 2026 Spring Town Meeting, voters rejected Article 27, a Cottage Cluster bylaw the Planning Board had worked on for more than a year, while Article 26, an accessory dwelling unit bylaw, passed, as The Wanderer reported. In The Wanderer's account, a Planning Board member pitched it as a way for people to downsize and stay in Mattapoisett on a small, manageable lot.
The Planning Board kept working on revised language at its August 3 meeting. At that same meeting it approved a preliminary three-lot subdivision plan on North Street, scaled back from an earlier four-lot concept, The Wanderer reported. The November 9 Special Town Meeting warrant had no zoning or housing article. Voters there did accept Cooper's Way in the JBL Estates subdivision as a public road, according to the meeting results.
None of the 2026 votes added a new kind of housing to Mattapoisett's zoning. The extra choice this winter comes from owners listing at last year's pace while buyers close fewer deals.
Questions buyers ask about the Mattapoisett market
Did Mattapoisett home prices really rise 10% in 2026?
The median for January through October 2026 rose 10.0% to $885,200. That figure is the middle of only 65 closings that spanned a very wide price range. The monthly median went from $1,285,000 in September to $690,000 in October, so it shows the mix of what sold more than the change in value of any particular house.
Is there much room to negotiate in Mattapoisett?
From January through October 2026, sellers who closed received an average of 95.3% of their original list price, and inventory at the end of October was 26.7% higher than a year earlier. Those averages describe the whole town. A well-priced house on a street buyers are competing for can still sell close to its asking price.
Where does the October data leave a winter buyer?
Mattapoisett had six pending sales in October 2026, down from 13 in October 2025. Fewer deals going under contract in the fall usually means fewer closings in early winter. That gives a buyer who is ready now more time and less competition than the townwide median implies.
If you're comparing Mattapoisett with its neighbors this winter, the useful questions are which part of that $350,000-to-$1.5 million range you're shopping in and how long comparable homes there have been on the market. That's the conversation we have every day at Martin Real Estate. If you own in Mattapoisett and want to know where your house falls in this year's sales, start with a free home valuation, and we'll walk you through the recent closings that compare to yours.